null : Java Glossary

If you execute some code like this:

x.doSomething();

The difference between a null reference and a reference to an empty object, (e.g. a freshly minted default object, empty collection or empty Iterator) is a major headache in Java. When dealing with other people’s code I want to strangle them. Why won’t they tell me when a method might return null or empty? Why won’t they tell me if a method can’t accept a null or empty object?

if ( x != null )
   {
   x.doSomething();
   }

1. Don’t return Lists from your methods; return Iterators instead. This way you can return the empty Iterator. The Iterator’s consumer does not need to deal specially with the null case. You don’t need the overhead of cloned empty List objects.
2. Create a singleton empty prototype object for each class that you pass around to act like null. The catch is, it may actually need to be a subclass so that its methods don’t actually do anything. You have to make sure nobody modifies the empty object. You can safely call methods on this object and nothing will happen. You can safely retrieve its empty/default-value fields. You would need an amanuensis to compose the code for such objects. The effort of composing them manually would be even more work than dealing with null. Using this technique would be more robust however. You would make all methods final so that they would inline down to nothing. This would be even faster than checking explicitly for null! Null is typeless. Empty objects are typed. This may or may not be considered a Good Thing™.
3. New Java syntax to insert if (x != null) more tersely: e.g. t!.doit(); is the same as if (t != null) t.doit();.
4. Use rigid Javadoc conventions to track whether a method consumes/produces null references, empty objects, or blank Strings.
5. Simply ignore java.lang.NullPointerExceptions. The catch is, there is no way to do that in Java. You can’t just ignore them and return to the code just after the call. You can’t turn them off. This would require a new language where NullPointerExceptions are simply treated as no-ops.