Bowling For Columbine
by Roedy Green ©2000-2008 Canadian Mind Products
Introduction
Michael Moore created a documentary called Bowling
For Columbine. In it he explored the question, why does America have
so much gun violence? He investigated various possibilities and discarded them.
He did not come to a clear conclusion. He did not make any specific
recommendations. Moore is an NRA member and won a NRA marksman medal as a teen.
The movie is not quite the ultra left liberal movie you might expect. He allows
people of all parts of the political spectrum, including the lunatic right to
make their points.
In the final scene, Charlton Heston (NRA spokesman) makes a dramatic point by
slowly and silently walking out of the interview — the NRA refuses to take
responsibility for the negative side of high gun use, only the positive side.
But it is Heston himself who makes this point so eloquently, not Moore. Moore
just records it. However, Moore wordlessly lets you know where he stands by
leaving a photo of six year old girl shot by a six year old boy in Detroit,
propped against a pillar in Heston’s house.
The Statistics
For some reason, in the USA, a large number of people are killed each year by
gun violence. Other countries don’t have this problem. The movie provides the
following statistics.
| Country |
Yearly Firearm Homicides
(i.e. not including accidents) |
|---|
| USA |
11,127 |
| Germany |
381 |
| France |
255 |
| Canada |
165 |
| United Kingdom |
68 |
| Japan |
39 |
What is Not the Cause
American gun ownership is exceptionally high. Perhaps that is the problem. Yet
Canada has equally high ownership, and they have much less problem.
Americans are exposed to ultra-violent video games. Perhaps that is the problem.
Yet so are the Japanese, and they have an extremely low rate.
Americans have a multiracial society. Perhaps that is the problem. Yet so do the
British, and they have low rates.
America was involved in a divisive civil war. Perhaps that is the problem. Yet
other countries had them too.
American watch ultra-violent movies. Perhaps that is the problem. Yet other
countries do to, watching the very same movies.
What Could be the Cause?
What is unique about America? What could possibly be a cause? I came up with
this list. Moore hints at some of these in his movie. This is primarily a list
of what is unique about America, and only secondarily about what are plausible
causes.
- The USA was the only western country to historically make extensive use of
slaves. Descendants of slave owners inherit the family attitude of fear of
blacks.
- The USA was the only western country that historically "recently"
killed large numbers of indigenous people. Descendants of pioneers inherit the
paranoia of those involved in the massacres.
- The USA’s TV news and reality TV is the most violent of any country. Adrenalin
keeps the ratings up. People come to believe they live in a world far more
dangerous than it actually is.
- The USA is the dominant economic and military power on the planet. Americans
have the normal paranoia of the wealthy that others are just itching to take it
all away.
- The USA had a period of prohibition which lead to the rise of the Mafia, and a
glorification of the mob in pop culture. Mob morality leaked into everyday life.
Prohibition provided high profits to the rum runners. A shot could go for $3
where prior to prohibition it was only a few cents. The need for transporting
and warehousing large amounts of liquor forced criminals to co-operate. They had
co-ordinate the bribing of thousands of officials. Criminals had to get
organised.
- The USA has a much stricter prohibition on drugs than other countries do. Other
countries focus more on harm reduction, treatment and education. The resulting
high profits stimulate violent turf wars between drug dealers.
- America is the most Christian western nation. It tends to favour fundamentalist
denominations that teach God is cruel, vengeful and violent. Right wingers
generally are doing most of the shooting. They learn the notion of violent
retribution from the pulpit.
- Americans have a love affair with the automobile. Most of the rest of the world
don’t use automobiles to anywhere near the same extent, even when they own them.
Americans isolated in their cars don’t rub shoulders with the same people day
after day the way people in other cultures do. The car lets an American range
over a huge territory each day. The automobile means Americans tend to live in a
world mainly populated by total strangers. There is a natural primate distrust
of strangers.
- The USA has the 2nd Amendment which gives a constitutionals right to "bear
arms". Americans tie gun ownership to virtue and patriotism more than
anyone else. They are much more emotional about guns.
- Protection of property is extremely important to Americans. It morally, if not
legally, justifies killing a suspected thief. People in other countries tend to
value life above property even the life of a burglar. People often kill family
members mistaking them for burglars.
- The USA is the most laissez faire capitalist of the western democracies. I
develop this idea later.
- Young Americans often enlist or are drafted into military service. Part of the
training for this is boot camp, a type of brainwashing where recruits are taught
unquestioning obedience to authority. They are also taught to kill perfect
strangers on command. There need be no reason at all for the murder.
Fear
Something I notice in the USA is that people are terrified of strangers and
criminals. I once spent a snowy, bitterly cold, night freezing outside in
Portland because no hotel would let me in without my passport which was locked
in a train station locker. I had plenty of cash, a debit card and credit cards.
One hotelier explained the law was somehow to prevent me from using drugs once I
rented the room. I still fail to see the logic, but then the paranoid are not
big on logic.
You don’t see this fear of strangers in Canada or Europe. People in Europe’s
public squares talk to each other — to perfect strangers. Little children
rush about all over talking to everyone. Everyone is relaxed.
This fear explains why people buy guns, but it does not explain why they use
them in anger so frequently against family members. It also does not explain why
the extreme fear exists, in the first place.
When Oprah had Michael Moore on her show, she also invited Barry Glassner. He is
the author of Culture of Fear: Why Americans Are Afraid of the Wrong
Things. He talked about how the media like to frighten the people because
it increases ratings.
 |
recommend book⇒The Culture of Fear: Why Americans Are Afraid of the Wrong Things |
| | paperback |
|---|
| ISBN10: | 0-465-01490-9 |
|---|
| ISBN13: | 978-0-465-01490-3 |
|---|
| publisher: | Basic |
|---|
| published: | 2000-04 |
|---|
| by: | Barry Glassner |
|---|
| Americans fear killer bees, razor blades in apples, and yet fail to worry about pensions being insufficient to live on. The media trick Americans into being unduly afraid of black people, especially black adolescents. The actual stats show that blacks are more likely to be the victims of crimes than the perpetrators. |
|
Moore also talked about the same false fear phenomenon as Glassner. When murders
went down 20%, media coverage of them went up 600%. The public got the illusion
crime was spiraling out of control. The razor blade in the apple story was an
urban myth, and yet now American children no longer get to enjoy trick or
treating.
Capitalism
The official American state religion of laissez faire capitalism may be the main
problem. Americans are supposed to be 100% independent. If they don’t make it on
their own, they deserve to die. As one Michigan militia member put it, "Why
call the police? Eliminate the middle man." Strangers are not people who
will help you if you get in trouble; they are people competing with you for food,
shelter, money and jobs. They are, in a sense, all out to kill you.
American capitalism’s neo-Darwinism asserts only the fittest should
survive. You should let the poor and weak and those without medical
coverage die or starve. This is counter to Christianity and to the way things
work pretty well everywhere else on the planet. American capitalism teaches you
to see others as rivals, competitors and even enemies.
The capitalism of other countries is tempered with the moral obligation to see
to it your fellow humans have the basics of survival.
As a result, Americans become mildly paranoid. It is them against everyone else.
Obviously they need guns with those terrible odds. Americans develop a
beleaguered mentality where they even sometimes start seeing family members as
enemies. Their frustration at everyone else boils over on their loved ones.
This is all so silly. When an earthquake hits, how do Americans really
behave? They go to heroic efforts to help each other out!
Please email your feedback for publication, errors, omissions, broken/redirected link reports
