| floppy |
- Free software.
- You can select just the files to backup, perhaps only those recently changed.
- You can restore your files to any other machine. No special hardware is needed.
|
- It would take a stack of floppies as high as the empire state building to backup an entire hard
disk.
|
| zip drive |
- You can select just the files to backup, perhaps only those recently changed.
- You can easily restore just the files you want, or even use them directly on the zip without
restoring.
|
- The media are expensive.
- You need a special zip drive.
- The disks only hold 100 MB.
|
| QIC tape backup |
- Runs nicely unattended, so long as your backup fits on only one tape.
- Easy to carry media offsite.
|
- Tapes must be restored using the exact same brand and model of tape drive — which may be hard
to find if your computer was burned or stolen.
- Tapes only hold typically 500 MB per tape.
- The media wear out quickly.
- Very slow. You have to let them run overnight.
|
| DAT (Digital Audio Tape) Tape |
- Runs nicely unattended, so long as your backup fits on only one tape.
- Easy to carry media offsite.
|
- Tapes must be restored using the exact same brand and model of tape drive — which may be hard
to find if your computer was burned or stolen.
- Only hold perhaps 2 gig.
- Media are very delicate. The HP (Hewlett Packard) drives eat tapes for breakfast and breaks down frequently. Mine
spent most of its first year in the repair shop. It died after the warranty wore out. It never worked
reliably even after being freshly repaired.
- About .
- Slow, especially to restore since it has to search the tape from end to end to find each file.
|
| Extra hard disk |
- Very fast backup.
- Can use files directly off the backup without restoring.
- Cheap. You can get huge disks for a few hundred dollars.
|
- It puts all your eggs in one basket. If a virus attacks one disk, it will attack the other, same
for thievery, a fire or a faulty power supply. You have only one backup. If anything goes wrong with
it, you have nothing else. With other forms of backup, you keep at least three generations, some
offsite.
|
| Extra hard disk on a caddy |
- Same benefits as disk.
- Can take disk out and take it offsite.
|
- When you add up the cost of three extra disks, to keep several generations of backup, this option
gets expensive.
- The caddy is a kludge. Eventually it will break or damage the disk drives. Hard drives are
delicate. They are not meant to be carted around. You may also accidentally take the drive out with the
power on and fry it.
|
| CD ROM (Read Only Memory) burner |
- Holds 600 MB per disk, a fair size, but still not big enough to backup an entire drive on one CD.
There is no mechanism to spill automatically to a second CD.
- You can restore to any machine that has a CD-ROM drive.
- You keep all your backups, scores of them since the media are not reusable. This protects
you if you corrupt your files, and don’t notice until much later. If you didn’t have the
old backups to go to, all you would have are backups containing corrupt copies of the file.
- You can choose which files to backup.
- Blanks are about
each plus a
per disc CPCC (Canadian Private Copying Collective) media levy as a piracy tax. Last revised/verified: 2008-03-02
- The media are very robust. Magnetic fields won’t damage them. Dropping them on the floor is
unlikely to damage them.
|
- You cannot backup and restore the Windows registry, just datafiles. Decent operating systems
don’t have that disgusting registry. Its sole purpose is to lock programs into running only on
Windows. Because of that deliberate designed-in Microsoft limitation (a problem with nearly all backup
methods), you cannot restore applications. You must reinstall them all from scratch.
- The Roxio (née Adaptec) Easy CD creator program can’t remember which directories you
like to back up. It insists you tell it afresh each time — which can take an additional 10
minutes per backup, and the process is quite error prone. CD Creator remembers which individual
files you backed up last time, but not which directories. If you tell it to back up the
same files, the problem is it won’t back up any new files or directories.
- The Roxio (née Adaptec) Easy CD creator program requires about 16 MB of free disk space
while it is copying. to buffer the transfers to the cdw. If you try to use your computer for something
else during backup, the program may not be able to keep up with the fixed speed cdr, and the whole CD
will be ruined.
|
CD ROM burner
with Norton Ghost Image Backup |
- like CD ROM burner, but lets you back up and restore everything, even the registry.
|
- When you back up, you need to backup an entire partition. You can’t select individual files.
This means you waste time and CDs
backing up your *.exe and *.dll files every day, even though they
have not changed.
- Ghost runs under DOS (Disk Operating System), so there is strong possibility it won’t support your disk drive or
CD-ROM burner. It can’t use Windows, NT or Linux drivers. It needs DOS drivers. You need to find
and install DOS disk drivers for your SCSI (Small Computer System Interface) controllers, SCSI disks, CD ROM burner and Ethernet card.
DOS can’t see drives that don’t have any FAT (File Allocation Table) partitions on them, though Ghost sometimes
can. This is not something the novice can tackle. If DOS/Ghost won’t support your CD-ROM burner,
you need about a gigabyte of free disk space in an unused NTFS (New Technology File System) partition, both to hold the a compressed
image of the partition and the CD-ROM image. You then later boot back to NT and back that image file
up. It can be quite a challenge getting Plug & Play in BIOS (Basic Input Output System) to work for DOS, and to collect the
latest versions of all the ancient old DOS drivers. Before you buy Ghost, make
sure you can access your disks, CD ROM burner (as a reader), and your LAN (Local Area Network) when you boot to DOS from a
floppy. If you can’t do that, Ghost won’t work on your machine.
- The backup will take dozens of CD s, and at about
each (including levy), so you won’t be doing that frequently. Each partition needs to start a
fresh CD.
- Unfortunately when you restore, you restore everything even your data files back the way
they were at the time of the backup. You can’t restore just a single file. Ideally you
combine this method with Easy CD Creator to backup just data files later. Then your restore an
entire partition with Ghost, then restore your more recent data files on top of that.
- To use it you must insert a master CD and a special floppy, then reboot, then insert a series of
blank CD s, then reboot back to NT. It is not something you can do unattended.
- The user interface is something only a Unix guru could love, with a zillion obscure command line
switches. It is quite intimidating, quite unlike the other Norton utilities. It refers to the drives
and partitions by physical number not the more human-friendly drive letter, OS (Operating System), or volume label. You
can’t easily specify more than one drive at once to back up.
- To backup or restore, you have to reboot to DOS to run Ghost. Windows won’t let you fiddle
with the registry while it is running.
- Ghost optionally compresses the backup files.
- Ghost backs up FAT (Windows), NTFS (NT) and EXT-2 (Linux) partitions.
- Norton support people won’t talk to you unless you pay them.
|
HP 9210i CD ROM burner
with included disaster recovery software |
- like CD ROM burner with Ghost, but does not require huge amounts of free disk space. It gets about
1 gig of files per CD, and it automatically splits partitions over CDs.
|
- Very tedious since it produces 5 floppies for disaster recover as well. The backup program is badly
written making you reinsert the floppies in random orders, and sometimes asks for a disk it already
has. Further it excruciatingly slowly writes many tiny files individually instead of building a disk
image of the floppies and copying them in one fell swoop to physical floppy.
- Beware! This scheme has an almost fatal flaw. You must restore to a disk partitioned identically to
the original. It is up to you to manually record the FDISK partition information and to restore it. You
may not be able to do that unless you restore to an identical drive to the original.
|
DVD (Digital Video Disk) burner
with Windows burning software
|
- like CD ROM burner holds 8 times more. Holds 4,700 MB per disk, a fair size, but still not big enough to backup an entire drive
on one DVD. There is no mechanism to spill automatically to a second DVD.
- You can restore to any machine that has a DVD drive.
- You keep all your backups, scores of them since the media are not reusable. This protects
you if you corrupt your files, and don’t notice until much later. If you didn’t have the
old backups to go to, all you would have are backups containing corrupt copies of the file.
- You can choose which files to backup. You can zip them first for compaction.
- Blank DVDs
are about
each without any CPCC media levy as a piracy tax. Last revised/verified: 2008-03-02
- The media are very robust. Magnetic fields won’t damage them. Dropping them on the floor is
unlikely to damage them.
|
- You cannot backup and restore the Windows registry, just datafiles. Decent operating systems
don’t have that disgusting registry. Its sole purpose is to lock programs into running only on
Windows. Because of that deliberate designed-in Microsoft limitation (a problem with nearly all backup
methods), you cannot restore applications. You must reinstall them all from scratch.
- If you don’t remember to click eject when the disk is finished, the directory won’t get
written to it, and you will have an effectively empty disk.
|
BackupToZip with a DVD Burner |
I was so frustrated by the flaws in all the backup software available, I wrote my own and put it out
into world free with Java source code. It is very fast, especially if you use Take Command copy /u to copy the zips to a USB (Universal Serial Bus) flash drive. It is very simple to use, a minimalist backup.
You tell it a list of directory trees you want backed up, and it makes a mirror of them in a zip file. You
then copy that zip file to DVD, CD, USB flash drive or even hard disk. (So far that is no different from
making an archive with WinZip and backing it up). The magic comes later when you re-run the program. It
very rapidly updates the archive. It adds new files, deletes ones from the archive you have discarded and
updates files that have changed. (In contrast, WinZip won’t automatically delete files for you.) You
can them backup up the amended archive again to DVD. You can have several different zip files for large
backups. |
Unfortunately it does not include an image backup, just file by file. It does not automatically split
archive files into pieces if they get too big for a single DVD. It is up to you to either group your
backups to keep the archive size in reason, or use a copying program that can split large files. |
| Nero 10 with a DVD Burner |
Nero provides a comprehensive package of 20 utilities for . A friend of mine uses it and says anything else is a waste of time. The Nero
entry gives more detail. |
Unfortunately it does not include an image backup, just file by file. |
| Acer with a DVD Burner |
Acer gets around the problems of Norton Ghost using three clever tricks:
- The put an auxiliary stripped down copy of XP on a hidden partition.
- They put a compressed copy of the disk image of what a machine looks like fresh from the factor in
this hidden partition.
- They don’t try to write the CDs
from DOS or other miniature OS.
When you make a snapshot, the alternate XP copy boots up and snapshots the system image. Since your copy
of the OS is not running, everything is nicely frozen for its portrait in time. Then it boots back to
Vista or the main XP. Then it uses an ordinary backup program to write the snapshot to any mixture of CDs
and DVDs.
If your disk it totally trashed and you have no backups, you can still restore your system to factory
conditions by booting the alternate partition and restoring from the compressed factory disk images. |
The main problem with this approach is the only way to get it is to buy an Acer computer. It comes
bundled and pre-installed on all their machines. They call it e-Recovery.
The other downside of this approach is it needs enormous amounts of free disk space to work. You need
room for copies of every sector on your hard disk that contains data, and the DVD images containing the
data with the embedded Reed-Solomon error correcting codes. So in theory you need perhaps twice as much
free space as you have filled! And usually Acer image backup seems to demand even more free space than
that. It seems overly partial to only using contiguous space on drive D:. |
| TeraByte Image for
Windows with a DVD Burner |
No frills image backup of a partition.
|
|
| NTI with a DVD Burner |
- holds 4.7 gig (4700 MB), eight times the capacity of a CD.
- Blank DVDs
are about
each without any CPCC media levy as a piracy tax, Last revised/verified: 2008-03-02
which is quite cheap for the capacity compared with other media.
|
- If you want to back up just a little, you still use an entire disc.
- You need to buy three different NTI programs:
- NTI (NewTech Infosystems) Backup Now! to do a file by file backup and restore.
- NTI CD & DVD Maker Platinum/Titanium to copy DVD s, burn music to DVD.
- NTI Drive Backup! to do an image backup.
You can save a little money buying them as a bundle. Acer bundles Backup Now! and CD & DVD Maker
Gold (no Mp3 support) with their computers.
|
| Drive Snapshot with a DVD burner |
This program does an image backup to DVD. Through the magic of a virtual drive, it even lets you
restore individual files from your image backup. It works without having to reboot. Somehow it creates a
coherent snapshot in time of your entire disk without having to freeze it with a reboot-style snapshot. You
can carry on working even while the backup is taking place. With other backups you are locked out of your
computer sometimes for hours. I am baffled how they could possibly pull this off. Perhaps the image is not
fully unified. It also supports Linux EXT2/3/Reiser partitions. It is reasonably priced at
|
It needs sufficient free disk space to store all the disk partition images. Needs DOS to restore a
system partition. This means there is no guarantee your hardware will be supported just because it works
currently under W2K/XP/W2003/Vista. Command-line driven. This is a plus for
scripting, but a bit daunting for the novice. The documentation is somewhat geeky. The company is based in
Germany. |
| Acronis True Image
10 Home with a DVD burner |
This program does an image backup to DVD. It also does file by file backups. It also lets you restore
file by file from the image backup. Acronis is the company that makes Acronis Disk Director It costs at . It has ways of backing up just the settings for a number of common utilities. You don’t need to do
all the grunt work to track down the settings files and registrentries to compose a snap.btm for those apps. Does full, incremental (just changes since last incremental backup)
and differential backups (all changes since last full backup). You can continue to use your PC (Personal Computer) during
backups. You can download the trial version. The restore is clever. It
restores the crucial clusters first, then lets you start working almost right away. In the background it
restores clusters as your programs request them. Your program is unaware the disk is not yet fully
restored. It just experiences a tiny delay. It can restore partition structure. It lets you create a
bootable CD to restore with in case your system it so hosed it cannot boot. You can restore to a bigger
hard disk and it will automatically proportionately grow all the partitions. |
It requires a permanent special partition called the secure zone to hold the
compressed partition images awaiting copying to DVD. This partition is logically invisible to ordinary
programs. Other backup programs tie down the image work space only during the backup. To back up, it needs
to reboot to a miniature Windows-like OS in a special partition. Though the program is fully menu-driven,
it is complicated with many options. It might overwhelm the casual user. |
| Norton 360 net backup |
This program use the Internet to automatically back up your files to a Symantec Server. It costs
per year for three machines. The main advantage is that it is automatic. The other big advantage is the
backup is offsite where it cannot be stolen or destroyed. It is up to Symantec to backup your backup. |
- Internet connection is orders of magnitude slower than a CD or DVD writer.
- You have to trust Symantec to protect your data from snoops after it arrives on their site, and
trust them to transport it securely over the net.
- You need a working OS with Norton installed to restore. It is for protecting individual files not
the system as a whole.
- There is a 2 GB limit on how much you can back up.
- This is an auxiliary backup to your primary DVD image and file-by-file backups.
|
| Carbonite
net backup |
This program use the Internet to automatic al back up your files to a Carbonite Server. It costs
per year or
a month. The main advantage is that it is automatic. The other big advantage is the backup is offsite
where it cannot be stolen or destroyed. It is up to Carbonite to backup your backup and put it in a vault
offsite. Carbonite does incremental backups in the background of recently changed files. You don’t
have to do anything other than install the software. There is no limit on the size of your backup.

|
- Internet connection is orders of magnitude slower than a CD or DVD writer.
- You have to trust Carbonite to protect your data from snoops after it arrives on their site, and
trust them to transport it securely over the net.
- You need a working OS with Carbonite installed to restore. It is for protecting individual files
not the system as a whole.
- This is an auxiliary backup to your primary DVD image and file-by-file backups.
|
| USB flash
drive |
You can use a USB flash drive, aka thumb drive, as a backup device
- A 32 MB flash drive holds as much as 7 DVDs.
- A flash drive is reusable.
- A flash drive is orders of magnitude faster than a DVD or tape.
- You can clip it to your keychain and have all your files with you instantly to restore wherever you
go. It is unlikely both your computer and your keys will be stolen at the same time.
- This sort of backup does not require any sort of software, other than perhaps WinZip or other archiver, so you know you can restore even if you lose
the backup software.
- If you empty a flash drive, you can use it for disk caching
|
You need to buy at least three flash drives to start so you have more than one backup and can ensure at
least one of the backups is offsite and any time. You might want to also backup to DVD from time to time
for an archival backup. You have to keep your wits about you which flash drive to backup to, and which to
rotate offsite. You could buy three colours of flash drive, but you need to keep a diary of what is on
which flash drive. You can’t label the flash drive itself. |
|---|