Kalām was an Islamic scholar centuries ago. He came up with an argument for the plausibility of the existence of a god. Modern Christian Creationist, William Lane Craig, added to the argument and claimed it proved the existence of the Christian god.
Kalām’s original version went like this:Whatever begins to exist has a cause;
The universe began to exist;
The universe has a cause.
William Lane Craig’s version goes like this:The universe has a cause;
If the universe has a cause, then an uncaused, personal Creator of the universe exists, who sans the universe is beginningless, changeless, immaterial, timeless, spaceless and enormously powerful;
An uncaused, personal Creator of the universe exists, who sans the universe is beginningless, changeless, immaterial, timeless, spaceless and enormously powerful.
What’s wrong with this argument?
- We can excuse Kalām because he did not know this, but the unrepentant liar William Lane Craig certainly does. We have known for over a century that, at the quantum level, particles pop into and out of existence without cause. Further, we know that atoms of radioactive elements spontaneously decay without cause. The actions are completely unpredictable. We can even use that unpredictability for cryptography.
- Both Christians and Muslims claim the universe is a special case, but refuse to even consider that it could also be a special case in not having a cause.
The universe’s cause could be quite different from the way Craig proclaims:
- It could be a pressure build-up.
- It could be a god created in turn by another god.
- It could be a god with barely enough ability to incompetently construct a universe.
- It could be a statistically improbable quantum event.
- It could be brushing up against another multiverse.
- It could be Zeus or Clarus the Dog Cow.
Craig is leaping to conclusions.
- Even if Kalām were true, it is still not evidence for the existence of god. It is just a lawyers’ trick for getting people to sign up for Christianity. It is just a plausibility argument designed to persuade the naïve.
|Baby Naming||choosing a name for baby 2017-07-01|
|Funerals||Funerals and corpse disposal. 2017-05-21|
|Evolution Glossary||Glossary of Terms used in Discussing Evolution and Creationism. 2017-05-17|
|Yahweh is Fictitious||Why I am very sure Yahweh is fictitious. 2017-07-12|
|Books about Religion||Books about religion, atheism and evolution. 2017-06-27|
|Why I Am Not A Christian||Bertrand Russell’s classic 1927 essay on why he is not a Christian. 2017-07-17|
|Evidence||Evidence for God. A short sci-fi story. 2017-08-20|
|Deprogramming||Ethical ways to free Christians of their delusions. 2017-05-17|
|Intelligent Design||Evolutionary theory does include Intelligent Design, just not the way Creationists imagine. 2017-07-15|
|Did a God Write the Bible?||Why it is highly unlikely a god wrote the bible. 2017-05-21|
|Separation of Church and State||The necessity of preserving the separation of church and state. 2017-08-01|
|Combating Kristianity||Why I believe it is necessary to combat Kristianity, non-violently of course, by exposing its lies, wishful thinking and tall tales to the light of truth. 2017-08-16|
|Noah||Why it is unlikely that God wrote the entire Bible. A list of Biblical oopsies (inconsistencies). Why the story of Noah is a tall tale in the same league with the tales of Paul Bunyan. 2017-08-12|
|A Bible Study Guide||The parts of the Bible the churches don’t want you to notice. 2017-08-10|
|King James Bible||The complete text of the King James Bible in HTML format. 2017-01-02|
|Is There A God?||Exploring the big questions. Is there a God and if so what is He like? 2017-08-14|
|The Real God||The nature of the real God. 2017-07-17|
|Godless Quotations||Short Tweetable quotations about religion and atheism. 2017-01-02|
|Quotations about Religion||Quotations about religion, especially Christianity, from both atheists and believers. 2017-08-22|
|Quotations about evolution||Quotations about evolution vs. creationism 2017-08-21|
|Quotations from Christians||Quotations from obnoxious Christians, usually in favour of bigotry or ignorance. 2017-08-22|
|Unjustified Certainty||The problem of unjustified certainty, especially religious fanaticism. 2017-08-16|
|Church Tax Subsidies||Why I think we should phase out church property tax subsidies. 2017-01-02|
|Was Jesus Gay?||Was Jesus a homosexual? Decide for yourself on the validity of the biblical evidence. 2017-07-12|
|Tennessee Law Book||If the Religious Right gained power, how the laws of Tennessee would be worded. 2017-07-06|
|The New Ten Commandments||The existing set of commandments focus on trivia and miss the major sins. I have reformulated them to bring them up to date. 2017-07-02|
|life after death||various beliefs about what happens after you die. 2017-05-21|
|CCism||A new religion based on Cosmic Consciousness. 2017-07-13|
|fatalism||religious and secular fatalistic philosophies. 2017-05-21|
|Rational Morality||An alternative to morality based on religious myth. 2017-05-21|
|Are We Alone?||Are we alone in the universe? Is there life in other parts of the universe? 2017-07-13|
|Christian Apology||The apology I would like to hear the pope to read on behalf of all Christians for the harm they have done to our planet with their nutty beliefs. 2017-07-17|
|Living Love||My cult, founded by Ken Keyes Jr. It teaches techniques to reduce mental suffering. 2017-08-22|
|Gay Civil Rights||The battle between equal civil rights for gays and right wing Christianity. 2017-01-02|
|Feedback||Read feedback from readers of the religion section. If you don’t want your message and my reply publicly posted, please let me know. 2017-05-21|
|Christmas Carols||Lyrics to 69 Christmas carols. 2017-01-02|
The darkest places in hell are reserved for those who maintain their neutrality in times of moral crisis.~ Dante Alighieri (1265 1321-09-14 age:56)
This page is posted
Optional Replicator mirror
Your face IP:[220.127.116.11]
You are visitor number|